Comments and likes have no value

The social and economic world struggles daily with the inundation of opinion.

But what is opinion worth if it costs nothing to produce?

Ages ago, when “letters to the editor” were the only way to share your opinion with the world at large, such offerings had worth. It costs something to write a letter, type or print it out, apply postage and walk it to the mailbox.

Today, your opinion, your likes or hates, your thumbs up and down, your LOLs or TLDRs or random STAR clicks have zero value. No, I misstate that. They have less than zero value. These days, gobs of reviews, a million claps, and a thousand smiley faces have negative value — negative because they cannot be trusted.

When information no longer contains truth it become propaganda.

How much effort does it take to click a button? Or write a computer script that clicks them for you? What cost to you is that half-second of time? This devaluation of our opinions is at the heart of why social media sucks these days. But how to reverse this trend?

To me the answer is simple: if you value your opinion enough to share it with the world then it should cost you something to publicize it.

  • Want to leave a product review on Amazon or Target or whatever ecommerce site? Then you MUST have purchased that product. Purchased and NOT returned it (returns should be shown as a separate category).
  • You want to “like” that post? It will cost you a penny.
  • You want to write a comment? Then cough up a nickel.
  • You REALLY like that post by your favorite author? Then donate a quarter or a dollar directly to them. (See: The Content Economy)

Your opinion may have value, but only if you spend the time, effort and considered reflection to imbue it with honest, heartfelt truth.

6 thoughts on “Comments and likes have no value

  1. This is great. But let me dig through my copy of “The Age of Surveillance Capitalism” and leave you a quote that refutes this opinion. The “likes” “comments” and other emoji’s is what addicts us to social media and we leave behind us a trail of consumer behavior which fits us like a glove to a hand, and this behaviorism is monetized and sold to corporations for targeted, timely advertising. Well, maybe I don’t have to find a copy of that book. I paraphrased the concept fairly well.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Alas, I agree that clicks serve more to drive marketing and demographic profiling, helping create our own homogenous bubbles. As a librarian tho, I am still inclined to the “free” speech feel of cost free commenting. It’s a tricky balance. “We have transformed information into a form of garbage.”
    –Neil Postman, Technopoly

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Well, hello and welcome.
      It’s a pleasant surprise to see your name here. This particular missive ties in with a bigger topic, one I’ve been trying to champion for years — The Content Economy.

      Your mom will be gladdened to hear that my writing skills continue to progress. It is a tough task, the hardest I’ve ever attempted.

      I just came off of a month of unemployment (Covid-economic victim) where I spent the time writing #SepSceneWriMo over on my other, edgier blog.

      I’ll not bend your ear/strain your eyes any further. Alicia, thanks for stopping by, Dave.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s